Bait are a group of items that can be used to increase the odds of catching a specific rarity of fish. Common, rare, and epic baits can be bought from Fisherman Joe, while all rarity bait can be found occasionally in the Wandering Merchant.
| Rarity | Name | Effects | Price(Wandering Merchant Price) | Image |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Common | Bread | Sets common fish chance to 75% and provides 5% faster fishing | $750(350) |
 |
| Worm | Sets common fish chance to 90% and provides 5% faster fishing | $1000(500) |
 | |
| Rare | Shiner | Sets rare fish chance to 35% and provides 5% faster fishing | $2000(1000) |
 |
| Minnow | Sets rare fish chance to 50% and provides 10% faster fishing | $3000(1500) |
 | |
| Epic | Shad | Sets epic fish chance to 15% and provides 5% faster fishing | $3500(1750) |
 |
| Crab | Sets epic fish chance to 25% and slows fishing speed for 10% | $4000(2000) |
 | |
| Legendary | Chicken Liver* | Sets legendary fish chance to 10% and provides 15% faster fishing at night | N/A($5000) |
 |
| Mythical | Chicken Nugget* | Sets Mythical fish chance to 5% and slows fishing speed by 20% | N/A($10000?) |
 |
| Special | Cut Bait | Increases size and weight of fish by 0.5% and decreases fishing speed by 10% | $5000($2500) |
 |
| Trophy Bait* | Increases trophy chance by 5% | N/A($15000) |
 |
* This bait cannot be bought from Fisherman Joe, only from the Wandering Merchant